I re-posted my query to javaee-spec-users after seeing no response on the jpa-spec users list. A reply from Linda DeMichiel on the javaee-spec list looks promising.
Separate discussion (twitter) suggests it's conference season so everyone's busy and sidetracked as well.
The spec proposal does indeed list:
Support for the use of "fetch groups" and/or "fetch plans" to provide further control over data that is fetched, detached, copied, and/or used in merging.but I'd seen no discussion of it on the EG list, which I've been monitoring since near start. (UPDATE: There'd been a wee bit, I just missed it.) I didn't realise they were working to an ordered, specific agenda, though it certainly makes sense to tackle such a big task in small chunks like that.
The JPA 2.1 spec proposal also has some other good stuff. Points of particular interest to me include:
- Methods for dirty detection
- Additional event listeners and callback methods; availability of entity manager to callbacks
One thing that isn't there that perhaps should be is handling failure more cleanly. Currently one needs to clone entity graphs before attempting to persist them using a tool like
org.hibernate.util.SerializationHelper, because they may be in an inconsistent state if a persist operation fails. It's slow and ugly to need to serialize/deserialize to clone an entity graph, but hard to get around because dynamic weaving and enrichment means you can't properly clone an entity just by allocating a new one and copying properties into it. Worse, you have to handle all the cascades yourself. Many common use cases involve situations where failure is normal: serialization failures of serializable transactions, optimistic locking issues, etc. Often you want to re-fetch the entities and re-do the work from scratch, but that's painful if you have user-modified state in those entities and all you want to do is retry a merge after a database serialization failure.
Guess I'd better pipe up about that too. It isn't news, but if it isn't on the agenda maybe it should be added for discusson.
Now is the time to join the jpa-spec users list on http://java.net/projects/jpa-spec and pipe up about practical, real-world issues you face with JPA. Even if everyone's out conferencing, email queues up nicely.